Thursday, February 3, 2011

Guns & Roses

Images: Memorial Takes Shape Outside Of School - Photos




I wish this blog were about the Rock Band that shares its name.

Sadly, I am writing today about the fatal shooting of Principal Sam Lacara at Placerville's Schnell Middle School yesterday. For the second time in a month, the news is filled with reports of another white male, lone gunmen, with a history of mental illnes, using a firearm in a place of business to shoot (and eventually kill) someone he had a grudge against. Parents told the media yesterday that staff and children alike had witnessed 44 year old John Luebbers' often yelling and talking to himself in the hallways at the school. Though never violent, even the children at the school reported that "Mr. John was weird sometimes."

For the second time in a month, I again ask, in order to obtain a license to drive a car: I have to register my car, provide proof of insurance, establish an address where I live and the car will be kept, pass two different tests (one written and one behind the wheel) pay the fees, and wait almost a month before I finally receive my license in the mail.

Why isn't it at LEAST that difficult to obtain a gun license? And better yet, why do we ONLY conduct a felony background investigation before we grant that license? Why don't we screen an applicants mental health status before we issue that license? For those of you that will scream "gun laws are already on the books, and tough enough" I say you're wrong.

No where in the Second Amendment do the framers of the Constitution grant weapons to ten year olds, blind people, or paroled murderers. Yet no one would suggest that these people should possess a firearm. Yet (as with the case last month in Arizona) we have no problem blindly handing a weapon and ammunition to someone who maybe mentally ill. In Jared Loughner's case, he frequently had outbursts in class, had been visited by College Police at his home, had been banned from the Campus, and frequently talked to himself. Yet a clerk in Tucson had no problem looking at him across the counter at a gun shop, completling his application and (after 7 days) selling Loughner the weapon of his choice. Again I ask, if the laws are on the books and they're tough enough, how do all of these people continue to LEGALLY buy and own a gun!?

A heated debate over on Facebook today reveals the far Right's often paranoid worry that the rest of America is trying to take their guns away. One respondent suggested that taking ones guns away is the step the Government takes before they take all of our other Civil Rights away. Another person referenced Hitler and the Nazi's taking gun ownership away from the Jews of Germany in the 1930's, as an escalation that eventually lead to mass murder of over 6 million people. But what about if gun saftey laws are just that? Gun safety. What if including some sort of check that involves screening the applicants mental health background isn't about taking YOUR Rights away, but keeping the rest of US safe!?

Maybe if we screened more carefully AND used the Laws currently on the books, there'd be a whole lot less guns causing a need for roses.

JB/11

2 comments:

  1. I definitely agree that people with mental issues should not be allowed have access to firearms...the tricky thing is how to determine who is mentally ill and then we are getting into HIPPA laws (protected health information). For instance just because someone is on mood stabilizing medication doesn't mean they are crazy or would ever do anything such as committing murder.

    Also many people with mental illness may seem totally calm/undisturbed if they are not agitated or upset...so there is no way for the average person to look in someones eyes and tell if they are going to commit murder with the gun they are buying.

    The only thing I could think of is if people were required to submit to psychological testing in order to obtain a license...then we are getting into a another gray area...or people would need to sign a release for their health information to be reviewed...I know I would never do that to own anything.

    For all the registered guns out there, people who legally own and handle their guns in a way that is safe for them and the community. Using a gun safe, going to the firing range for fun, etc. (I am an avid target shooter) There are just as many unregistered guns out there...actually more unregistered.

    I do hope there is a way to screen people more carefully but I am not sure what that is. Maybe increase the waiting period?

    It really is a conundrum one that I really don't have any answers too, but I enjoyed reading what you have to say about it. --Shay

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hey couldn't get my profile to post before so here I am!

    ReplyDelete